Keddie, California. A quadruple homicide. A missing teenager found three years later, 62 miles away. A letter that confessed to four murders — and was overlooked for decades. Composite sketches drawn by an amateur. Suspects who died free.
340,000+ subscribers across 107 countries
Case File Evidence
EXHIBIT A-01 / LOCATION MAP
"The phone was off the hook. All lights were off. Three boys in the back room — untouched."
— Sheila Sharp, April 12, 1981
How We Work a Case
Every Casefile episode is built on the same four pillars. No speculation dressed as analysis. No headlines repackaged as insight. Just method — applied with the patience of a detective reviewing evidence at 3 a.m.
Every known movement mapped against the official record. We surface the gaps — the hours unaccounted for, the witness who changed their story twice, the alibi that doesn't hold against the phone records.
Cross-referenced against court documents, police reports, and contemporaneous news coverage.
We don't accept the official forensic summary. We go back to the original evidence logs — what was collected, what was lost, what was never tested. The Keddie hammer sat in a pond for 35 years.
Analysis includes chain of custody documentation and known contamination events.
Every witness statement laid side by side. Where they agree, where they diverge, and where the divergence is statistically improbable. Under hypnosis, one witness saw two men. Under oath, the story changed.
Statements sourced from trial transcripts, police interview records, and sworn affidavits.
When investigators use an untrained amateur instead of FBI forensic artists. When a confession letter is "overlooked" for decades. We name the failures, the departments, and the systemic conditions that allowed them.
Cross-referenced against standard law enforcement protocols and FBI procedural guidelines.
"The letter stated: 'I've paid the price of your love & now I've bought it with four people's lives.' It was overlooked. For decades."
Evidence Reel
A quadruple homicide. A missing girl found 62 miles away, three years later. A confession letter overlooked for decades. The Plumas County Sheriff's Office faces accusations of a botched investigation that allowed the primary suspects to die free.
HAMMER RECOVERED 2016 / DNA EVIDENCE PENDING / COMPOSITE SKETCHES CONTESTED
Eleven bodies in barrels. A community that knew, and said nothing. How John Bunting cultivated a network of complicity i...
Three children vanished from Glenelg Beach on Australia Day, 1966. No bodies. No confirmed suspect. Nearly 60 years of t...
Thirty-five people killed. The legislative response that reshaped a nation's relationship with firearms. We examine the ...
Field Reports
I've listened to every true crime podcast that exists. Casefile is the only one where I finish an episode and immediately open a browser to verify the details myself — because it makes me want to go deeper, not just nod along.
Meredith Callahan
Criminal Justice Instructor, University of Melbourne
The Keddie episode broke me open. Not because of the horror — I knew the facts — but because the forensic failure analysis was so precise I could identify exactly which decisions allowed Smartt to die a free man.
Declan Okafor
Forensic Science Graduate Student, Sydney
I passed the quiz on my first attempt and got 'Cold Case Specialist.' Then I spent three hours in the episode archive verifying every claim they used as evidence. That's not a podcast — that's a methodology.
Priya Venkataraman
Armchair Investigator, Bangalore
The witness contradiction matrix in Episode 47 is more useful for understanding how eyewitness memory fails than half the academic papers I've read. I assign it to students.
Thomas Breckenridge
Psychology Lecturer, Auckland
340K+
Subscribers
107
Countries
230+
Episodes
9 yrs
Investigating
Assessment
Five questions drawn from actual episode evidence. Identify contradictions, spot forensic red flags, and rank investigative failures. Your result categorizes your analytical profile.
Forensic Failures
Witness Reliability
Evidence Chains
Questions use actual evidence from Casefile Episode 09. No trick questions — just the kind of analytical reasoning a detective applies to a cold case. Your result will reveal your profiler classification.